# Review buying decisions

Source: https://docs.tightly.io/help/commitments/act-review-buy-decisions
Reviewed: 2026-10-29

## Choose what you are reviewing

Open a product from **Buy plan** and open its **Product decision reviews**. Choose the **Expected receipt date** first. The review is for that date: evidence for one receipt date does not stand for another. Each row is one **Decision**: **Quantity**, **Size and colour mix**, **Source** or **Delivery**.

A review records who looked at those values and when. It changes no quantity, split, supplier, delivery or order, and it does not approve the buy. If a decision needs a saved choice first, save it in its normal control. A suggested quantity or a generated split is not a recorded decision.

## Read the review state

The **Review state** column reads one of four words:

- **Current review**: what was reviewed still matches the inputs Tightly can check.
- **Needs review**: those inputs have changed since the review.
- **Not assessed**: no review has been recorded for this date.
- **Missing evidence**: the evidence to assess it is not complete.

If the check cannot be made, open the review and read the evidence. Do not read an unavailable check as clearance. A banner reading "Some source evidence remains incomplete" means a source review can be recorded but cannot stand in for the full valuation that Sign off requires. A count across the full range also needs the receipt date chosen first.

## Record the review

1. In the row, choose **Review**.
2. Read the **Recorded input** and **Value** lists. **Open decision editor** takes you to the decision itself.
3. Choose **Mark reviewed**.

Mark reviewed saves the values and what they depend on, with your name and the date. If an input changed after you opened the review, the page says "Inputs changed. Open this decision again to review the current values." and the review is not saved. **Refresh inputs** reloads them. If the save fails, the page says "The review could not be recorded."; **Recover review submission** checks whether it went through.

**Review history** keeps every review, with **Reviewed by** and **Reviewed on**. A later change can make an old review stale without erasing who made it.

## Ask Tightly

Ask Tightly can offer a review for one product, one decision and one receipt date, against what it just read. You still need permission to record the review. Sign off is a separate step, taken when the whole buy is ready for approval.
